CLICK HERE to subscribe.
Get the latest articles from Tyranny of Style sent directly to your inbox!
By Joe Kucharski - January 7, 2014
When you think of a Disney animated film, spectacular costume design might not be the first thought that crosses your mind, but all that has changed with the recent release of Frozen. The costumes of the main characters capture a true sense of depth and believability that is absolutely remarkable for the genre. Frozen Art Director Mike Giaimo describes the film as “the most elaborate costume-animated CG film to date.”
Giaimo brought on designer Jean Gillmore to help him create the look he was after, which he describes as both “sumptuous” and “iconic.” I recently had the wonderful opportunity to find out more about the process of designing costumes for Frozen from designer Jean Gillmore.
Tyranny of Style: Can you tell us a little bit about the difference between character and costume design for animation, how it has evolved over the years, and how you found yourself in this niche?
Jean Gillmore: “‘Traditional’ animation did indeed handle the character costume design as an integral part of the cartoon graphic, and no distinction was made. In hand-drawn animation (2-D, or traditional), all sorts of cheats, morphing and distortions happen accidentally and are excused as part of the charm of the original moving art. But with CG (computer-generated) animation, because all of it is built /manipulated in the computer, the costume has to have more logic to it - seem more real, or it becomes a distraction to the acting of the virtual character. If not properly designed, textured, rigged and animated, the garments have a plastic quality, like everything is made of rubber or plastic, and sometimes even of the same material as the character themself! This is not acceptable to the human eye/brain, and a disconnect happens. This is the quality that has SO improved over the years to create a much more believable result on screen, regardless of the studio producing.
I never set out to be a costume designer for animation (I was known as a character designer for my first 10 years), but I always had a love and interest in historical/ethnic costume, so animation was just another arena in which to play. Over time, and not with my pushing for it, studio colleagues began to think of me as the costume person, so I was often handed the task of researching the period/place for details. Hey, my pleasure!! Fascinating for me to discover all the obscure (to animation) details about garment construction, shapes, details and particulars. It was paid detective work for me, and I still love it. And of course, then you have that knowledge forever. On top of my animation career, I used to like to design and sew event costumes to wear on the side, so that too had taught me a lot about construction and materials. Guess it was fate.”
Frozen, Elsa, early concept art. By Bill Schwab, Character Designer.
Frozen, Elsa, concept art.
T/S: Can you speak specifically to your role on Frozen as it relates to costume design and a snapshot of the design process?
JG: “I was brought onto the project early (after the story had been kicked around for a year or two), by special request of the Art Director, Mike Giaimo, who was both a previous Art Director (on Disney’s animated 2D picture, “Pocahontas”) and a personal friend. He knew for years of my interest in historic costume (we ran into each other at a vintage clothing show, reigniting our friendship after years), and thought I’d be the perfect person to collaborate with on this, his ultimate Disney fairytale vision. This was his first CG picture; interpreting his strong graphic sense and mastery of the 2D realm would take someone able to keep the integrity of his vision, while evolving it to work in the practical physicality of the 3D (virtual) world. This is where my costuming experience and brief background in consumer products paid off. No, this was not a titled position for me on this picture--- you’ll find me lumped in with the other Visual Development artist credits--- but I was brought on to do this very specific thing with Mike, to help make his vision reality, through costuming.”
Frozen, Anna's boots, early concept sketch. By Jean Gillmore.
Frozen, Anna, early concept art.
T/S: Animation seems to lend itself more to a stylized or loose approach to "historic" costume design- can you speak a little to the discussion of period, research of historic clothing, and the process for translating that for animation?
JG: “Traditional or hand-drawn animation is/was always about the ease and fluidity of drawing movement, about graphic viability and strength--- hence, the caricature and simplification of styles and periods. Merely a general sense of a period was and is used to roughly place the viewer in the appropriate time. Most of these scenarios are fantasy, remember, not striving for historical accuracy. After all, nobody really cared about the clothing; it was always about the character and what happened to them in the story. Costume, then, was strictly about entertainment, enhancing the character’s readability and personality. Still is, really. But 3D/CG animation has gradually made available- indeed, Frozen demanded it- a level of detail untried before. Standard budget and time constraints did provoke discussions about whether the level of detail desired would be worthwhile pursuing, but a very strong and technically creative tech team jumped on the challenge. Perseverance and capability have created stunning results.”
Frozen, Anna, concept art.
T/S: I was blown-away by the level of costume detail in Frozen- both of applied details such as trims and embroideries, as well as the quality of fabrics- from velvet, to suede, and sequined/beaded fabrics. Can you speak a little to the inspiration behind these wonderful detailed choices?
JG: “The A.D. had a dream, and I was privileged and determined to help him see it realized. Some of the relevant information I already knew, some was acquired by diligent online searching (imagery AND text). Mike had a sense of what he wanted, and knew exactly the color palate he would employ. Something Scandinavian, certainly, with as high a level of detail as could be achieved within reason. What followed were the real-world trips to Solvang, Norway, and innumerable photos and odd pieces of actual garments and trim. But while the whole picture is loosely based on real life material, most of the costumes are in fact “fantasy” in nature. True, my general approach was to meld the historic silhouettes of 1840 Western Europe (give or take), with the shapes and garment relationships and details of folk costume in early Norway, circa 19th century. Pieces like Anna’s traveling hat are made up from Mike’s intuited “cuteness factor” for Anna, and my simplification of an actual regional Norwegian cap. Elsa, the Snow Queen’s gown was to be simulated ice crystals, snowflakes and reflective surfaces common to ice in its various forms. Kristoff, the ice harvester, has much more rustic, primitive clothing styles and materials (the Sami people’s traditions were studied extensively), and the trolls, of course, have unrefined clothing made of the elements around them. Mike, and the team in general, never wanted to use any reference literally, but whatever would serve the effect of the design themes in the picture overall. At one point, I gathered some images of the crisp, graphic shapes typical of Dior fashions, thinking maybe that would help Mike articulate to the team part of his shape language for the entire picture. It did.”
Frozen, Hans, concept art.
T/S: Along that same line- quality of animation has really been improving for years and Frozen is no exception. Was there a team or process in place to provide physical samples of real fabric, trims, and embellishment techniques to the animators to aid in capturing the real world quality of the costumes?
JG: “There is a growing awareness in animation (overlapping into live-action CG animation) that clothing on animated characters can no longer merely be part of the graphically-silhouetted character itself, morphing and being “cheated” with the drawn line of traditional animation. Technology has now, for realism when context demands, necessitated treating clothing as almost a separate entity with its own properties and behaviors.
‘Look Development’ creates the digitally painted simulation of the appearance of surfaces; other departments deal with movement, anchoring (rigging) and weight/thickness/lighting of textile animation. Disney has a growing library of fabric types and samples, which Mike and I, in the course of the production, ran around madly supplementing with a myriad of real-world samples, supplying all the various departments what they needed to proceed. Many of our samples came from the Disney Parks costume division in Fullerton, California, where we got further education and recommendations. This collaboration translated directly to the walk-around costume interpretations for Disney’s Theme Parks, when that time came. It really helps when a studio has those kind of extensive resources!”
Frozen, Kristoff, early concept art.
Frozen, Kristoff, concept art.
This is truly a fascinating time for animation, and I believe Disney has set the bar quite high for films to come. I look forward to seeing more of this level of detail in animated costumes, and an increased role for designers of Gillmore’s caliber (one that possibly even involves a title!) to help elevate the field.
Thank you to Jean for her time and expert insights. If you haven’t seen Frozen, make sure to catch it while it is still in theaters!
Disney recently released additional original concept art for the character and costume design of Frozen. Enjoy these stunning images created by Brittney Lee and the team at Walt Disney Animation Studios.
Frozen, Elsa shoe detail.
Frozen, Anna and Hans ball costumes.
Frozen, King and Queen of Arendelle.